After his side conceded six goals against Manchester City last weekend, it was perhaps not surprising that the priority on Saturday for Manchester United boss Sir Alex Ferguson was defence.
United sacrificed some of their attacking instincts to gain a defender's favourite result of 1-0 against Everton at Goodison Park, and took their first steps to reducing the alarming number of chances that they have conceded this season.
If only the same could be said of Chelsea, who let five in against Arsenal in an eight-goal thriller at Stamford Bridge.
It was the latest in a bizarre run of results which has seen the Premier League's biggest teams toss away their usual cautiousness against each other and serve up a feast of goals.
Alongside the last two weekend's stand out results, Manchester City's 5-1 thrashing of Tottenham and Manchester United's 8-2 demolition of Arsenal have added to a notable quartet of in keeping with a season which has seen a rise in the number of goals scored and a goals per game ratio of 2.97 which is the highest since the 1967/68 season.
So why is that? In short, according to Match of the Day 2 pundit Lee Dixon, the Premier League's attacking is getting better and the defending is getting worse.
The former Arsenal defender believes inexperience contributed to the Gunners' defeat at Old Trafford, while City's huge win there was helped by the sending off of United defender Jonny Evans.
But he does admit that while teams have been more adventurous this season, defenders are being hindered by growing rule changes which have given their opponents an added advantage.
"Throughout the league there has been an emphasis on attack," he says. "We've seen sides like Swansea and Norwich have a go at teams but overall the one thing that stands out for me is the quality of the defending. It seems like it is at an all-time low.
"If you look at all the top teams, they have all had problems defensively. Chelsea can't seem to find someone to play alongside John Terry and he has been having a bad time himself. United's backline has been unsettled, with Nemanja Vidic having been injured, and Rio Ferdinand has had troubles.
"In my experience of defending the more you play together and the less often the back four changes, the better. When we played at Arsenal, virtually none of us really got any major injuries and if one of us did it was quite simple to get in someone to cover as long as they know what they are doing.
"United, Chelsea and Arsenal have all had issues at centre-back and if you mix that with teams being more adventurous then you've got a cocktail there for explosive games.
"Also, I genuinely think players are a little bit nervous of making tackles now because there are so many yellow and red cards flying around. It's made the game more exciting from a chances or goals point of view but I will be saddened if the art of defending is eradicated from the game and it certainly looks like it is going that way.
"There is no doubt that year on year there is a change in emphasis, and a change in rules. They've stopped the tackle from behind, and you'd probably say quite rightly, but I still think there's a place for good defending behind forwards.
"Certainly the tackle from the side has been outlawed in as much winning the ball is not enough. It's deemed now that you have to win the ball in a safe manner and not be a danger to the opposition. We don't want to see broken legs, and we want to rule out the over-the-top tackle, but I certainly think there is very little left in defenders' armoury.
"It's probably why you are seeing more shirt-pulling now, because there are only certain ways that you can stop a forward advancing towards your goal. Players are getting a bit tighter. You could give a player a little bit of space knowing that if he tries to take you on down the side you could get a tackle in. Nowadays, the tackle is very much on a knife edge when you go in for one because if you slightly mis-time it, you get a yellow card or sometimes a red.
"Defenders are staying on their feet more but that will lead to a completely different type of game, a more flowing game. That's fine. People will say 'Dixon is talking about ruining the game - stifling it', but it's not about that.
"As a defender, surely you should be allowed to be in a position where you take the ball off the opposition as fairly as possible? These days it seems to be heavily weighted in the forwards' favour and that's probably why you are getting these open and free flowing games.
"Maybe most people want more of it as far as the goals are concerned, but we have to be very careful that we don't turn it into a non-contact sport."
Dixon accepts that the quality of forwards in the Premier League has risen as the competitions' riches have allowed teams to attract the world's best.
And although there are examples of teams like Newcastle, who have made significant improvements, he still sees bad examples of defending every weekend.
"From the matches I see on a Saturday and Sunday, there doesn't seem to be an emphasis on organisation," he adds. "I'm sure teams work on it but it is quite easy to pick holes in things and see mistakes.
"In general there often seems to be something jumping off the screen. Was it like that 10 years ago? I don't think the mistakes were as prominent as they are now."
You can also discuss more tactical issues and follow me on Twitter
Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thefootballtacticsblog/2011/10/is_premier_league_defending_ge.html
אין תגובות:
הוסף רשומת תגובה